Is Goodwin's time up at United?

[BBC] United fans, we asked for your views after Sunday's Scottish Premiership defeat to Hearts. Here's what some of you had to say: Gary: I listened to Jim Goodwin's post-match assessment, he's either lying or delusional because he says he saw and what actually took place on that Tynecastle pitch are worlds apart. It was a shocking display, especially at the back. We cannot afford to be Jekyll and Hyde this season - zero shots on target and conceding four goals against a Hearts team missing players is unforgivable. Dave: Jim Goodwin said the people who weren't at the match may have thought that Hearts gave us a good hiding, well I was there and can confirm that they did give us a good hiding. Too many players were off the pace in the first half and in the second half when we got the ball in their box none of our players could manage anything other than tippy-tappy shots in the general direction of the goal. A very poor performance all round. David: Goodwin thinks a four goal defeat is a close game. Last season's defensive mess continues and with the change of players the only constant is the manager and the coaching staff. Are they capable of putting a team together who can defend? Not on this showing or many games last season Jenny: One of the strangest games I've seen. There was never four goals between the sides with United playing some nice stuff at times. Lachlan Rose worked his socks off and is already a fan favourite. Once he and the team click it could be a great season for Dundee United. Alan: Enough is enough, Goodwin has to go. He is tactically naive and keeps trying to defend the indefensible. We need a change at the helm. I know it's early season but it's another Goodwin team that is leaky in defence and offers nothing up front. There's a chance, like in previous seasons, of sleepwalking into a relegation battle. Come on United give yourselves a shake and wake up. Gordon: Absolutely rotten, a point against a poor Rangers side papered over the cracks. We're in trouble under Goodwin.