Barry Gets 9, Pickford With 8 | Everton Players Rated In Impressive Win Vs Newcastle United

Barry Gets 9, Pickford With 8 | Everton Players Rated In Impressive Win Vs Newcastle United Everton welcomed Newcastle United at the Hill Dickinson Stadium earlier tonight as they looked to secure a victory at home in the EFL Cup. The Toffees made a decent start to the game and took the lead in the 34th minute when James Garner got his name on the scoresheet. Hackden Hackney doubled his team’s lead in the 45th minute as David Moyes’ men went into the half-time break 2-0 up on the scoreline. Thierno Barry put the contest to bed in the 69th minute before Dan Burn got a goal back for the Magpies in the 88th minute. The match ended with Everton securing an impressive 3-1 win in front of their home fans. Let’s take a look at how each Everton player fared during the clash against the Magpies. He made a lot of crucial saves at the back and did enough to limit the opposition to just one goal. RB: Merlin Rohl – 7/10 Rohl performed his defensive duties well but offered very little going forward. CB: James Tarkowski – 7/10 He put his foot through the ball when he could and was good on the ball. CB: Jake O’Brien – 6.5/10 O’Brien did his fair share of defending and did enough to restrict the opposition from scoring more than once. LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND – OCTOBER 29: Jacob Murphy of Newcastle United is challenged by Hayden Hackney of Everton during the Carabao Cup Fourth Round match between Everton and Newcastle United at Hill Dickinson Stadium on October 29, 2026 in Liverpool, England. (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images) LB: Vitaliy Mykolenko – 7.5/10 He was a positive influence at both ends of the field. CM: Hayden Hackney – 8/10 Hackney caught the eye at times on both halves and ended the game with a goal and an assist to his name. CM: James Garner – 7.5/10 He worked his socks off in the middle of the park and managed to score in the 34th minute. RW: Tyler Dibling – 7/10 Dibling managed to shine at times but failed to register a goal. CAM: Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall – 7.5/10 He was a constant menace in the final third and has an assist to show for his efforts. LW: Tyrique George – 6.5/10 George caused a few headaches for his marker, but never looked like he would score. ST: Thierno Barry – 9/10 Barry was a real handful for the Newcastle defenders and managed to score and create a goal tonight. CM: Harrison Armstron – 6/10 He added some energy to Everton’s midfield. RW: Brennan Johnson – 6/10 His impact on the game was minimal. CAM: Charly Alcaraz – 6/10 He failed to influence the game.