Willock Gets 7.5, Dedic With 5.5 | Newcastle United Players Rated In Poor Loss Vs Everton

Willock Gets 7.5, Dedic With 5.5 | Newcastle United Players Rated In Poor Loss Vs Everton Newcastle United faced off against Everton at the Hill Dickinson Stadium earlier tonight as they hoped to secure a good result on the road in the EFL Cup. The Magpies made a slow start to the game and conceded the opening goal in the 34th minute when James Garner found the back of the net. Hayden Hackney doubled the home side’s advantage in the 45th minute as Newcastle went into the half-time break 2-0 down on the scoreline. Thierno Barry made it 3-0 to Everton in the 69th minute. However, Dan Burn got a goal back for the Tyneside club in the 88th minute. The match ended with Matthias Jaissle’s men suffering a poor 3-1 loss away from home. Let’s take a look at how each Newcastle United player fared during the clash against the Toffees. He made a couple of solid saves at the back, but failed to keep things solid at the back. RB: Amar Dedic – 5.5/10 Dedic did his fair share of defending but made a costly error tonight. CB: Fabian Schar – 6/10 He cleared his lines when he could and was a threat at the other end of the field. CB: Dan Burn – 7/10 Burn put his foot through the ball when needed and managed to score late in the game. LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND – OCTOBER 29: William Osula of Newcastle United shoots under pressure from James Tarkowski of Everton during the Carabao Cup Fourth Round match between Everton and Newcastle United at Hill Dickinson Stadium on October 29, 2026 in Liverpool, England. (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images) LB: Lewis Hall – 7/10 He was a positive influence at both ends of the field. CM: Nico Gonzalez – 6/10 Gonzalez earned possession back once and made a few decent chances in the final third. CM: Jacob Ramsey – 6/10 He worked hard defensively but offered very little going forward. RW: Jacob Murphy – 6/10 Murphy was not shy of having a strike at goal and was replaced in the 66th minute. CAM: Joe Willock – 7.5/10 He engineered a lot of inviting chances for his teammates to score and has an assist to show for his efforts. LW: Harvey Barnes – 6.5/10 Barnes managed to shine at times in the first half, but there was no goal for him. ST: William Osula – 6/10 He struggled to be a threat up top and was replaced at half-time. CM: Joelinton – 6.5/10 He was good on the ball. ST: Yoane Wissa – 6.5/10 Wissa was lively after coming off the bench. RW: Anthony Elanga – 6/10 He made one key chance in the final third. LW: Bazoumana Traore – 6.5/10 He made two decent runs with the ball.