Everton Eye This £26m Defender: Should Moyes Move In January?

Everton Eye This £26m Defender: Should Moyes Move In January? Everton have made progress under David Moyes this season, but their defensive planning still needs attention. James Tarkowski remains an experienced presence, while Jarrad Branthwaite represents a major part of the club’s future. However, Michael Keane’s contract expires in 2027, and Jake O’Brien has struggled to secure a regular role. With the January window approaching, Everton must consider how to protect their defensive depth without disrupting the current setup. Their summer recruitment focused on other areas, including attacking and midfield additions, leaving the centre-back group largely unchanged. Branthwaite’s reported £80 million valuation reflects his importance, while interest from wealthier clubs could eventually test Everton’s resolve. Planning for that possibility now would give Moyes more options if the squad changes next year. According to Sport Witness , which cites Italian outlet Tuttomercatoweb, Everton and Crystal Palace have contacted Lecce about Tiago Gabriel. The 21-year-old Portuguese defender has attracted interest from AC Milan and Fiorentina as well, while his agent Jorge Mendes continues to explore potential opportunities. Fulham reportedly tried to sign him late in the summer. Gabriel joined Lecce for around £1.7 million in January 2025 and recently extended his contract until 2030. The Italian club reportedly want between £21 million and £26 million for the centre-back, whose eight Serie A appearances this season have included two goals. His height and strength could help Everton defend crosses and threaten opponents at set-pieces, while his physical approach suits Moyes’ preference for disciplined defenders. Should Everton look for Gabriel or trust their current defenders? LECCE, ITALY – SEPTEMBER 13: Tiago Gabriel of US Lecce during the Serie A match between US Lecce and AC Monza at Stadio Via del Mare on September 13, 2026 in Lecce, Italy. (Photo by Francesco Pecoraro/Getty Images) Everton should seriously consider a January move, particularly because Keane’s contract situation and Tarkowski’s age make long-term planning essential. Gabriel could learn alongside experienced defenders before taking on a larger role, giving Moyes another aerial presence at both ends of the pitch. However, Everton must establish whether he can handle the Premier League’s pace and improve his distribution under pressure. A reported fee of up to £26 million represents a substantial commitment, especially amid uncertainty surrounding The Friedkin Group’s ownership plans. Gabriel may need time to adapt, so Everton must decide whether his potential justifies the immediate cost. With Milan and Fiorentina competing for his signature, delaying a decision could make negotiations harder. Moyes should look for Gabriel if scouting confirms his readiness, but Everton must avoid paying a premium based on potential alone.